Sellafield clean-up cost reaches £67.5bn, according to parliamentary report
04 February 2013
The cost of cleaning up nuclear waste and decommissioning the Sellafield site in north-west England has now reached £67.5bn, according to a new report. The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) of the House of Commons said the authority dealing with the country's nuclear legacy had not been able to show what value it was getting for the taxpayer.
Nuclear waste storage at Sellafield: photo NDA
It said the "enormous" legacy of nuclear waste at the Cumbria had been allowed to build up, with no indication of when the cost will stop rising. The PAC also said it was not clear what wider economic benefits had been achieved from the "enormous" amount of public money spent at Sellafield - currently around £1.6b a year.
The Public Accounts Committee report follows criticisms of Sellafield’s waste storage programmes by the National Audit Office (NAO) in November.
PAC chair Margaret Hodge said a solution to the problem of long-term storage of nuclear waste was as far away as ever following last week's decision by leaders of Cumbria County Council not to press ahead with a study for a possible underground storage site.
Successive governments had failed to get to grips with the "critical problem", Ms Hodge said, adding: "An enormous legacy of nuclear waste has been allowed to build up on the Sellafield site.
"The Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA) believes that its decommissioning plan is credible but it has not been sufficiently tested and uncertainties remain - not least around what precisely is in the waste that lies in the legacy ponds and silos.
"It is unclear how long it will take to deal with hazardous radioactive waste at Sellafield or how much it will cost the taxpayer. Of the 14 current major projects, 12 were behind schedule in the last year and five of those were over budget."
Ms Hodge said taxpayers were not getting a good deal from the NDA's arrangement with international consortium Nuclear Management Partners on a plan to improve Sellafield Ltd's management of the site.
The report said deadlines for cleaning up Sellafield had been missed, while total lifetime costs for decommissioning the site continued to rise each year, reaching £67.5bn.
"It is essential that the authority brings a real sense of urgency to its oversight of Sellafield so that the timetable for reducing risks does not slip further and costs do not continue to escalate year on year," it said.
It added: "Basic project management failings continue to cause delays and increase costs, while doubts remain over the robustness of the plan, in particular whether the Authority is progressing the development of the geological disposal facility as quickly as possible," said the report.
Ms Hodge added that Sellafield was an area of high unemployment, but she said there should be a clearer ambition that the £1.6bn of public money being spent at the nuclear site each year was contributing to creating jobs in the region and elsewhere in the UK.
John Clarke, who started last April as CEO of the NDA said: "Prior to the NDA's inception there was no credible lifetime plan for Sellafield and tough decisions about how we ultimately decommission the site had simply been put off for future generations to deal with.
"We are now facing up to those challenges and for the first time we have a proper plan in place for the decommissioning of Sellafield which lays out in detail programmes of work for every area of the site.
"Since the creation of the NDA in 2005, the financial investment at Sellafield has increased from £900m to over £1.5bn a year. Of course, not everything has gone smoothly on such a complex and highly-technical programme, and the report has rightly pointed to areas where we and the site need to do better."
Gary Smith, National Secretary for energy and utilities at the GMB union, said: “There needs to be immediate change at the top of the consortium and a radical re-evaluation of the piecemeal hiving-off of the nuclear sector to private companies that are clearly ill-equipped to cope.”
Sellafield stores the bulk of the country's high and intermediate level nuclear waste in ponds and silos at the west Cumbria site, some dating back to the 1950s.
Contact Details and Archive...